Percelli's Pizza

Discover Percelli's Pizza in McArthur, OH, offering delicious cauliflower crust, flavorful subs, sausage, chicken tenders, and fresh salads. Enjoy takeout and friendly service at 417 S Market St. Call +1 740-596-5281 for your perfect meal!

Welcome to Percelli's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Percelli's Pizza
Percelli's Pizza
Percelli's Pizza
Percelli's Pizza

Located in the heart of McArthur at 417 S Market St, Percelli's Pizza offers a delightful blend of traditional pizza and modern flavors. This inviting spot radiates a warm, welcoming vibe, perfect for gatherings with family or friends. Whether a pizza aficionado or a subs enthusiast, every menu item promises satisfaction. The community buzzes with praise for the cauliflower crust, which allows pizza lovers to enjoy a healthier option without sacrificing taste. Don't miss the chicken tenders or their superb salads, either; they shine equally as stars in this culinary lineup. With takeout options available, enjoying a meal from Percelli's fits seamlessly into any lifestyle, be it a quiet night in or a festive occasion.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

417 S Market St, McArthur, OH 45651, United States

Phone

+1 740-596-5281

About

The Culinary Story

Percelli's Pizza
Percelli's Pizza
Percelli's Pizza
Percelli's Pizza

Setting foot in Percelli's Pizza feels like entering a local haven. The restaurant embraces the community spirit of McArthur, where friendship and delightful food coincide. Founded with tradition in mind, Percelli's blends time-honored pizza-making techniques with local flavors that create dishes both comforting and innovative. Each pizza is crafted to order, ensuring freshness in every bite. Popular options like the BBQ Chicken and the Greek Supreme showcase a fusion of flavors that keep customers returning for more.

What's more, the delightful subs, such as the Steak and Pizza Bread, add a layer of excitement to lunch and dinner choices. With meals to accommodate all appetites, the restaurant emphasizes the importance of community and connection. It holds a special place in local hearts, making it a go-to spot for many. Peak dining hours on Sundays attract a bustling crowd, hinting at the passion for the food served here.

If you arrive during quieter “happy hours,” you can enjoy a relaxed meal, making it an ideal setting for intimate conversations or family dinners. Percelli's also supports local ingredients whenever possible, showcasing the best in season's produce for salads and toppings. This commitment to quality reflects the care and attention put into each dish. Whether gathering around their iconic pizzas or diving into a hearty pasta meal, diners celebrate food that feeds the body and soul.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday3 AM-10 PM
  • Monday11 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-10 PM
  • Friday11 AM-11 PM
  • Saturday2-11 PM

Percelli's Pizza is all about variety. They serve an extensive menu that caters to diverse palates, including 41 unique dishes. From traditional supreme combos to delicious subs like Italian and Ham and Cheese, each option holds a special allure. Families often rave about the pasta dinners; the Chicken Alfredo and Lasagna are particularly popular. The atmosphere is relaxed, with a friendly staff ready to serve you in a timely manner, ensuring that you never wait long to savor your meal. Plus, the takeout service lets you grab your favorite dish on-the-go, making it easy to enjoy Percelli's delights anywhere. Those pizza cravings can be satisfied both dine-in and take-out.

Percelli's Pizza

The exterior of Percelli's Pizza is inviting, marked by a cozy façade that welcomes passersby. The restaurant features a charming outdoor seating area that perfectly complements warm evenings in McArthur. This space buzzes with laughter and good cheer as patrons enjoy their meals al fresco. The vibrant signage and cheerful decor reflect the enthusiasm emanating from inside. Percelli's embodies a laid-back vibe, inviting both families and friends to unwind and enjoy good food together. An ambiance of warmth and community encourages diners to linger and enjoy every moment spent there.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Fantastic as always. Never gets our orders wrong and has the best salads. I highly recommend the "CBR" Salad with the red sauce. Definitely plan to come back more often! Have some photos of the place as well. -Stellar

D
Dakota F.

AWSOME 18in pepp....lobby smells like mozz cheese sticks which smells great to a fat man. Mozz cheese sticks look, taste, crunch, and string they way you want them too. Awsome job. Sorry no pics, it was too good to take a pic of just 1 slice and an empty box

b
budget f.

Visiting from out of town and thought their pizza was great and cheap!

K
Katie W.

The red dressing is so yummy, you can get small cups or a pint, it's good on everything chicken bites, pizza, salad etc!! My go to pizza is mushroom and sausage .

S
Stark

We were camping at Lake Hope and the staff gave great, understandable directions. Google maps will tell you they are in the middle of a forest. Then when we arrived they gave us directions for the grocery store and checked the hours because Google had the wrong hours listed. After establishing that the staff are friendly and fantastic we were hoping the pizza wouldn't disappoint. The only gluten free option is a cauliflower crust, which I am not usually a fan of, but I gave the veggie lovers GF a try. It was loaded with toppings and was delicious! There seem to be a few choices for pizza in MacArthur. Stop looking at the other options and just go here. You'll be happy you did.

N
Nate M.

This is an absolute Mom and Pop Gem! After 4 hrs of hiking in hocking hills, my family craved for pizza. We searched for a pizza place that has more than 4 stars! And my husband just recommended to pick one that has an Italian name! Ha! The trick worked! The pizza that we got was absolutely delicious! Very authentic pizza! My kids devoured the 18" supreme ultimate deal pizza! I myself had 6 slices! Thats how yummy it was!!

n
nina